Tuesday 5 February 2013

Neptune Novices Hurdle 2013 - Preliminary Thoughts

The New One

Winner of the Warwick trial for this race and runner-up in the HQ version on heavy ground in late January, grabbed late to be beaten a head by At Fishers Cross. Prior to this narrow reversal he had won all three of his hurdles starts (6L 6th in the Champion Bumper) on soft and good to soft ground.

Two of his four starts have come away from Cheltenham resulting in facile successes of 26L and 16L. Of far more interest are both the simple fact that he has been to Cheltenham twice to race over the Neptune trip; and then the qualities he displayed in those races. Both the esteem in which he is held by connections and his gradual curve of progression add to his overall profile.

The New One's first race at the track was on good to soft ground on his second start. In contrast to his later visit, this run (beating Village Vic nearly 3L) foregrounded a measure of grit and stamina, staying on strongly to assert up the hill with both horses pulling 20L clear of the third. Village Vic has not gone on to compliment the form at all in two subsequent runs (latest 6th of 8 in the Tolworth Hurdle).

The New One's second race at the track was on heavy ground. The race was quite clearly defined for a trial with the third, Coneygree, and the winner, At Fishers Cross both openly considered Albert Bartlett types after the race, probably before. Despite being closely grouped on the long run to the last flight The New One was able to 'quicken' around 3 to 4L ahead of his rivals but the move was either too early or too tiring in the ground and his lead was eroded just before the line.

The New One has demonstrated an ability to travel strongly through his races although it should be mentioned that his hurdling is sometimes far from fluent. Whether he actually quickened or not coming down the hill last time out is quite an interesting question. He may have just been running at a higher tempo than his staying rivals who were about to dig into their stamina reserves. What probably happened was a pace differential - The New One still moving strongly at one pace running downhill at the moment his staying rivals were switching off the bridle to race behind it, with the winner duly kicking in. If The New One had truly quickened away then he probably would have opened up a winning gap. The New One's run style may therefore share similarities with Oscar Whiskey and, perhaps, last year's winner of this race Simonsig: horses capable of a long sustained run at a very high tempo rather than a cruise-and-quicken style of say a Grandouet or - where more evidence might be needed - Puffin Billy. For the Neptune, staying right to the line after having the speed to be put into the race turning the bend is a crucial component and so far The New One has demonstrated this.

Better ground may prove quite important to The New One. This is not because he cannot cope with soft ground - he clearly can - but because his long sustained run to the line will be much more assured on goodish ground than, as seen in his run at Cheltenham on heavy, if the ground was tiring making sustaining his gallop to the line more gruelling and punishing. A fascinating runner and a leading contender.

Pont Alexandre

Has raced over hurdles twice, winning the G1 Navan Novice Hurdle over 20f by 13L on heavy ground on debut and winning the G2 Synergy Security Solutions Novice Hurdle by 11L also on heavy ground and in atrocious weather.

It is clear that Pont Alexandre is thought to be one of his trainer's best novices. Running in a G1 on debut illustrates this clearly enough as does registering a combined win margin of 24L in his two starts. The question is what characteristics in particular has he displayed to date.

Pont Alexandre handles heavy ground and on both starts he has raced from the front and made all. On his debut he jumped noticeably right over his hurdles and this aspect of his jumping reappeared on his next start. This would be a slight worry in a fast-run race on better ground around Cheltenham but the conditions there will be markedly different (ground, field-size, pace) so it is not certain whether he will repeat the same tendency. On the whole his jumping is good and clever although when asked to race by his jockey, most notably at the last hurdle on his recent start, he was very novicey indeed.

Given the softness of the ground it may be significant that Pont Alexandre has been ridden to make all. Many time novices are given cover, experience of racing amongst horses and so on but here none of that has been on connections mind which may indicate two things: he is so highly regarded it is not considered necessary and a clear sight of hurdles and staying out of the way of inferior horses was more important; and also 20f may be the minimum of his requirements.

Pont Alexandre is quite difficult to assess. He has jumped right, relished heavy ground and is a future staying chaser. Yet he has run all over G1 and G2 races in Ireland with the minimum of fuss. Interestingly though we know far more about him than we did about Fiveforthree from the same stable, who debuted as late as February 13 over 2m on soft ground before winning the Neptune on his second start. Fiveforthree had a fine turn of foot, however. Mikael D'Haguenet was given four runs prior to his win in this race and perhaps one more run from Pont Alexandre would help to assess his true potential. He is clearly a leading contender with the word soft in the going. 

Taquin Du Seuil

Winner of the Sandown December trial for this race and the 2013 Challow Hurdle, both on heavy ground. He has won 3 of his 4 starts over hurdles (all comfortably); on his second start at Ascot he was no match over two miles for the Supreme Novices candidate My Tent Or Yours but ran to the line against that rival over a trip shorter than ideal.

Taquin Du Seuil is a highly talented middle distance novice hurdler. He can be keen in his races and physically he appears to have much more growing to do. A feature of his last two runs has been his high knee action and he clearly handles deep ground very well. In his only defeat to date either the slightly quicker tempo of a two mile race or the better ground (or both) led to some untidy hurdling but he remained prominent throughout and wasn't cast aside easily by a high class opponent.

A (limited) stayer on the flat in France his type of performance at the festival is probably ground dependent: he has cruised through his recent contests so doesn't lack speed on soft ground but equally on better ground he will be put to the test much earlier and may lack the pace to be effective at the end of a race, particularly if held-up as he has been over 20f to try to help him settle. Assessing him accurately is quite tricky but this season may just be a year too early for him on the evidence to hand thus far. 

Rule The World

Winner of the 2013 Slaney Novices Hurdle by 16L on soft to heavy ground. He has won 3 of his 4 starts over hurdles this season on soft and heavy ground. His sole defeat to date came over 3m on his second start.

Perhaps the most impressive aspects of Rule The World's performances this season have been his even and professional distribution of his energy and his hurdling. It could be said that his hurdling is among the most impressive of any of the novices so far, appearing to respect his obstacles he clears them fluently and on a correct stride. The only time this deserted him slightly was when narrowly defeated over 3m on his second start, where three out and two out he perhaps didn't adjust himself quickly enough. In his races Rule The World settles very well; he is not keen and doesn't pull which is a very interesting aspect of his overall profile: he moves through his races evenly and comfortably and over 20f he has outclassed his rivals with the minimum of effort.

Rule The World is a half-brother to 2008 Neptune Novices Hurdle runner-up Venalmar. Venalmar had the same kind of campaign (one typical of the trainer in general): four runs capped off with a win in the Slaney Novices Hurdle then kept fresh until March where he ran into the classy Fiveforthree in a thrilling finish. Venalmar's Slaney win had more substance but even if Champagne Fever hadn't have run poorly Rule The World gave the impression he would have won in smart fashion and his overall profile looks set to give him a big chance of going one better than his half-brother with the prospect of better ground likely to play to his strengths.


No comments:

Post a Comment